The "Purple Cow" in Local Economic Development: Beyond Generic Charm

The concept of the "Purple Cow," coined by marketing visionary Seth Godin, is about being remarkable – so outstanding and unique that you naturally grab attention and stand out from the crowd. In a field of ordinary brown cows, a purple one is instantly memorable and worth talking about. For local economic development, this means moving beyond generic improvements and instead, identifying and amplifying what makes a community truly one-of-a-kind, thereby attracting investment, talent, and visitors.

I explain this in my book Unleash Your Unfair Advantage, builds upon this idea, asserting that every community possesses an "unfair advantage" – something it does better than anyone else, a unique edge that sets it apart. This "unfair advantage" is the community's "secret sauce".

Here's how the "Purple Cow" concept, powered by a community's "unfair advantage," applies to local economic development:

1. The Pitfall of "Brown Cow" Communities: Blending In is Failing Out

Just like a field of brown cows, many communities blend into the economic landscape. They offer similar incentives, focus on common industries, or promote themselves with uninspired slogans. This leads to:

  • Sameness: Communities often copy what others are doing, resulting in "generic offerings (chain stores, standardized events, cookie-cutter streetscapes)" that lead to a "race to the bottom".
  • Overlook Factor: When nothing stands out, communities are easily overlooked by businesses seeking new locations, residents looking for a home, or tourists planning a trip. As Crowder notes, "in a crowded economy, blending in is a path to oblivion".

2. Discovering Your Community's "Purple Cow" (Unfair Advantage)

A community becomes a "Purple Cow" by actively identifying and leveraging its "unfair advantage" – that distinctive quality or characteristic that other places cannot easily replicate. This isn't about minor tweaks; it's about a fundamental shift in perspective.

I emphasize that this "unfair advantage" can be:

  • A Quirky History or Cultural Legacy: "a quirky history, a cultural legacy, a geographic quirk, a passionate people".
  • Unique Local Assets: "a historic architecture charm, an unusual local craft, a tight-knit multicultural community, or even a legendary festival".
  • Overlooked Strengths: It might be "hiding in plain sight". For example, a town that lost its main factory might have a surplus of cheap workshop spaces and skilled tradespeople, perfect for a "maker economy" if someone recognizes the potential.
  • The Authenticity of Place: Unlike artificial shopping centers, downtowns have "a real place" that developers often try to "recreate, but usually in inauthentic ways".

3. Unleashing the "Unfair Advantage": The "Purple Cow" in Action

Once a community identifies its "unfair advantage," the next step is to "double down" on it. This involves strategic action and an entrepreneurial mindset, as outlined in our BusinessFlare® approach:

  • Capitalize: This is about turning your unique strengths into "tangible economic gain". If a community has a rich musical heritage, capitalizing means "preserving and repurposing an old warehouse as a music venue, or you create a music incubator program for young artists, or encourage music-related businesses (instrument shops, recording studios) to cluster downtown". It's about "leveraging the thing you have that others don't".
  • Expose: You might have remarkable assets, but "if nobody knows about them, their impact is limited". Exposing means "actively telling your community's story and showcasing its advantages to the world". This could involve savvy social media campaigns, hosting tours for investors, or ensuring local success stories are covered in the media. It's about ensuring your "unfair advantage doesn't remain a best-kept secret".
  • Embracing Creative Destruction: To make way for the new, communities must be willing to let go of outdated practices. This "creative destruction" might mean replacing old retail concepts with "new uses (brewpubs, tech startups, residential lofts) that are driving today's economy". Communities that "allow this process to unfold, rather than fight it, tend to grow faster and stronger".
  • Entrepreneurial Leadership: Downtown leaders need to shift from a bureaucratic mindset to an entrepreneurial one, acting with "urgency, creativity, and opportunism of a startup founder". This involves prototyping, hustling, and not being afraid to pivot. Instead of "slow-moving consensus building," it means being proactive, intervening, and focusing energy on those willing to collaborate.
  • "Unreasonable Hospitality": This concept, exemplified by Michelin-star restaurateur Will Guidara, is about "going above and beyond to make people feel surprised and truly cared for". For a downtown, it's about creating "stories to tell their friends, a memory that cements their love for your Main Street". This could be a downtown ambassador going the extra mile or a business owner creating a special moment. It's the "little, thoughtful actions that show people they're valued and welcome".

By adopting these principles, communities can transform from "brown cows" into "purple cows" – destinations that are not only economically vibrant but also genuinely memorable and talked about, fostering organic growth and a sense of pride. The ultimate goal is to "create a downtown experience that people can't stop talking about".

 

By